Select a different country or region to view content tailored to your location.
In the fast-paced world of forex trading, choosing the right broker is crucial. IG and TD Ameritrade are two popular options, each with unique strengths and weaknesses. This comparison will dive into the key features of both platforms,helping you decide which one best suits your trading style and goals.
The radar chart above illustrates the comparison between IG and TD Ameritrade across several key metrics, with the highest possible score being 100 in each category.
At FxScouts, our mission is to assist traders in finding the broker that best suits their needs. Comparing brokers side-by-side is an effective method to achieve this goal. We evaluated IG and TD Ameritrade, using our standard criteria: trust and regulation, trading platforms, costs and trading conditions, and educational and market analysis resources.
Trust and regulation are crucial when selecting a Forex broker. A broker’s credibility is largely built on its regulatory status. We spend considerable time verifying the safety of each broker by examining their regulatory licenses. The more top-tier authorities regulating a broker, the higher its trust rating.
In our comparison:
Based on these findings, IG earned a higher trust rating than TD Ameritrade.
When comparing brokers, trading costs are a significant factor. We consider the minimum deposit required to open an account and ongoing costs, including spreads and commissions. We measure the cost to trade one lot of EUR/USD using the broker’s account with the lowest minimum deposit, including both the spread and any commission charged.
We found that IG has overall lower trading costs than TD Ameritrade.
Trading Platforms Offered Traders prefer brokers that offer a variety of trading platforms. We rate brokers higher if they support multiple platforms like MetaTrader4, MetaTrader5, cTrader, and proprietary platforms.
Copy trading is beneficial for beginner traders or those unable to trade full-time. In this case both IG and TD Ameritrade offer copy trading.
A broader range of CFD instruments provides more trading opportunities. IG offers a greater variety of instruments compared to TD Ameritrade:
For those interested in trading cryptocurrencies, IG offers 10 cryptocurrencies, while TD Ameritrade offers 0 cryptocurrencies. Therefore, IG is the better choice for cryptocurrency trading.
Traders prefer brokers with quick and cost-effective deposit and withdrawal processes. We favor brokers that process withdrawals within 24 hours using multiple methods without charging fees.We found that neither IG nor TD Ameritrade charges a withdrawal fee. Overall, IG has better deposit and withdrawal processes than TD Ameritrade.
We often find that brokers offer very little in the way of educational materials, forcing traders to use other third-party sites or self-educate elsewhere. Beginner traders need well-structured, well-presented materials in multiple formats to get a good start at trading. More experienced traders also benefit from webinars led by experts in the field and advanced trading strategy sections with new trading ideas.
IG and TD Ameritrade both have very good educational support. Both IG and TD Ameritrade offer educational support for more experienced traders.Access to frequent and high-quality market research and analysis is crucial.
We found that IG offers better research analysis than TD Ameritrade and that both IG and TD Ameritrade offer frequent webinars.
Founded in 1974 and regulated by the CFTC, IG is a low-cost CFD broker with a long history of providing safe and secure trading and a vast range of trading instruments.
Our research found that IG has over 320,000 clients worldwide and has been the largest CFD broker in the world by revenue for the last few years. It has two low-cost trading accounts and a spread betting account with no minimum deposit requirements and offers trading on over 17,000 instruments, all of which can be accessed on its award-winning app and web trader platform.
For more traditional investors, IG also runs a fully licenced stock brokerage on the side. And in addition to a wide range of trading tools, IG has a world-class selection of educational and market analysis materials to get new traders started.
Founded in 1975 and CFTC-regulated, TD Ameritrade is a popular U.S. broker listed on the New York Stock Exchange. Known for its award-winning thinkorswim platform, TD Ameritrade caters to traders with different experience levels and different financial goals.
Forex traders can open an individual account with no minimum deposit requirement (unless trading with margin) with a spread of 1.2 pips (EUR/USD) and no commissions. These trading costs are around the industry average.
TD Ameritrade has solid educational resources, including a learning center with instructional videos, online courses, and trading demonstrations. It also offers a wealth of market highlights and analyst reports from Dow Jones and Benzinga, among others.
The only drawbacks of an otherwise excellent offering is the lack of funding methods, limited to bank-related transfers and that no support is offered for popular third-party platforms like MT4 and MT5.
For more detailed reviews, please read our comprehensive assessments of IG and TD Ameritrade.
You can either use the arrow button or swipe on mobile
Broker | Overall Rating Our overall rating evaluates brokers on platform quality, fees, service, regulation, and instruments. Higher scores reflect better performance and reliability. | Official Site Click to visit the broker’s official website for more information and to open an account. | Min. Deposit The minimum amount of money required to open an account with this broker. | Min. Spread | Trading Cost | Licenced by Displays the financial regulators licensing the broker, shown by national flags, ensuring compliance with financial standards for safer trading. | Accepts Traders from %s | Compare Select two brokers using the checkboxes to compare their features, fees, platforms, and more side by side. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | USD 100 | 0.70 pips | USD 8 |   | es | |||
 | USD 0 | 0.60 pips | USD 6 | | es | |||
 | USD 0 | 0.20 pips | USD 10 |    | es | |||
 | USD 1 | 0.10 pips | USD 5.40 | | es |
Select another broker to another broker to compare features, fees, and platforms side by side.
Alison and Chris cover a range of topics, including how to choose a Forex broker, safety and regulation, how to reduce your risk, trading psychology, trading platforms, and trading strategies, among others.
The FxScouts podcast helps beginner Forex traders get the best start to their trading careers.
